Home » Admissions Committee » 7 Lessons Learned from “Admission” the Movie

7 Lessons Learned from “Admission” the Movie

Posted by on Monday, April 1, 2013

Last week, I went to see the new Tina Fey movie Admission, in which she plays an admissions counselor going through a recruitment and application cycle at a highly competitive university.  My original intention was to write this post as a Fact v. Fiction piece, pointing out all of the ridiculous liberties that were taken by the filmmakers to make the college admissions process look as scary as possible and let all of you know how things really are here at Vanderbilt.

Of course, some such liberties were taken: There is no “DENY” stamp or whiteboard of angry parent quotes, our office does not live and die by our university’s U.S. News and World Report ranking, and we do not keep our final admissions decisions in an Excel spreadsheet on the director’s desktop.  These things aside, I was pleasantly surprised at how many truths about the admissions profession came through in the film and resounded with my own two years of experience here at Vanderbilt.

Truth #1: Travel season is crazy and unpredictable, in the best way possible. In an effort to recruit a diverse and dynamic freshman class year after year, we travel to all types of schools, speaking to high school students and counselors, and spreading the word about what our institution has to offer.  Sometimes this means going beyond city limits, driving down winding roads or across fields, and ignoring my GPS when it tries to tell me that a building simply does not exist.

Truth #2: Admissions counselors are human, too. As you know, we each serve as application evaluators and advocates for the students in our respective territories.  After reading our students’ files and finding out all of the wonderful things they have accomplished both in and out of the classroom, most of the time we really want them to end up on our campus in the fall.  Sometimes this works out, and sometimes it doesn’t, which means the admissions counselor, not just the student, is often very disappointed by an unfavorable decision.

Truth #3: The students get us through it. Life happens to all of us – whether it’s a sudden illness, the stress of juggling multiple tasks, a particularly gloomy day, or your long-time boyfriend leaving you for an obnoxious blonde in the English department (as in the movie).  At the risk of sounding sentimental, however, none of these things are any match for the privilege of meeting a group of incredibly intelligent and interesting students, hearing their passion for pursuing an education at the school you represent, and giving them the shot at this experience that they truly deserve.

(John Russell/Vanderbilt)

Truth #4: We are looking for students who love learning for its own sake. College is not simply a place to make connections and build a resume (though it can certainly serve those purposes well) – it is also a place to stretch the limits of your own knowledge and explore academic areas that may or may not be directly relevant to your eventual chosen career path.  We look for and value this passion for learning in the selection process, and our esteemed faculty do a fantastic job of capitalizing on this passion once students arrive on campus.

Truth #5: Many of you have it more together than I do. As the competitiveness of our applicant pool continues to increase, I am more and more impressed by the remarkable things you all have accomplished in your high school years.  Between the stratospheric test scores, the national championships, the founded nonprofits, the part-time jobs, and the hundreds of hours of meaningful community service, you often put into perspective my ability to watch Psych and answer emails at the same time, or cook the world’s greatest meatloaf.

Truth #6: “If this is the right place for you, this is where you will end up.” One of the most important factors in any college search process is the idea of “school fit,” and we take this idea very seriously here at Vanderbilt.  We are not just looking for the 1600 best testers in the applicant pool, but for the students who we think are the most likely to succeed within and contribute to our specific community.   A student who is a great fit at Vanderbilt may be less so at another equally competitive university, and the reverse may also be true.

Truth #7: “There is no secret formula to getting in.” If there was, I would have sold it Arthur-Slugworth-style and moved to Aruba months ago.  The truth is, by the time you apply, everything you need to do in order to be admitted has already been done or not.  The only part left is to be clear, be comprehensive, be honest, and be you.

As I’m sure you have heard, we recently mailed decision letters to all Regular Decision applicants for the class of 2017.  As some of you are receiving your decisions and celebrating your many offers and others look forward to starting your own application process in the future, I hope that these truths can serve as a window into the process we have been going through over the last several months.  As always, please feel free to send questions via this blog or reach out to your admissions counselor at any point – we are here for you!

Posted in Admissions Committee, Application Process, College Rankings, Uncategorized and tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

  • Carolyn, Does the admissions staff have any idea what percentage of students who were wait-listed will be offered admission into Vandy? We’ve been reading all the acceptance letters and I have to admit there is a certain amount of envy. Regardless, our high school senior is undaunted and still hopeful that there will be room for one more National Merit Finalist next year in Nashville.

    • Carolyn Pippen

      Hi Greg,
      It would be difficult for me to give you that particular percentage, as the number of students on the wait list will fluctuate drastically over the next several weeks. I can tell you that, over the last few years, about 10% of the Vanderbilt freshman class has been admitted via the wait list.

  • Hi Carolyn! I really enjoyed this piece and reading the opinions of those working in a college admissions office on the fact vs. fiction of the admissions process. I think that Truth Six is the more relatable one to me. Last year, Vanderbilt was a dream to be accepted to; sadly though, I did not make the Fall 2012 class. I was disappointed to say the least, but I made the best of the situation and have been succeeding phenomenally at my current university. Still, this year I applied as a transfer student to Vanderbilt because I believe it is where I’d fit in best. I hope that one day I will “end up” at your campus and we can learn together!!

  • Anonymous

    Any sense of engineering students who may be offered admission?

    • Carolyn Pippen

      Could you clarify your question?

  • PlanoCelloMom

    Hi Carolyn! Love this article. I haven’t seen the movie, but now I will have to! I am the parent of a graduating Vanderbilt University senior and I am wondering how long you have been the Admissions counselor for the DFW area?

    • Carolyn is on vacation for a few days, but I didn’t want your comment to rest unanswered! She’s been the counselor for DFW for just under two years.

      • PlanoCelloMom

        Hi Ryan, Thank you for answering in Carolyn’s stead. Your courtesy is appreciated. As I mentioned, I have a Vanderbilt senior, which means she was a high school senior during the 08/09 school year. Do you know who was the admissions counselor for the DFW area was at that time? THANKS!

        • No problem! I’ve asked around and it seems like either Mike Drish or our director John Gaines would’ve served the DFW area at that time.

          • PlanoCelloMom

            hmmm…. Sorry to be high maintenance, but is it possible to find out for sure or to share their email addresses with me so that I may ask? I would like to send a thank you letter. As I look forward to commencement, I can’t help look back with gratitude to all those who helped make this day reality.

          • That’s very kind of you. Which high school did your daughter attend? It’s possible that her counselor no longer works here, but I’ll do my best to track the name down!

          • PlanoCelloMom

            Plano Senior High School, Plano, Texas “GO Wildcats!!”

          • I have spoken with our director and he’s certain it would’ve either been Mike Drish or Chancey Phillips Thompson, both of whom no longer for our office. I’m sorry I couldn’t be of any further assistance!

  • Alexandra

    This was helpful! I loved reading it



we're talking about

Academic Advising Academic Life Admissions Committee Advice for Parents Alumni Application Process Balance Be a Vandy Blogger Blair School of Music College Application Guides College Confidential College Fairs and VU Visiting Your High School College of Arts and Science College Rankings Commencement Common App Commons Community Service Demonstrated Interest Diversity at Vanderbilt Early Decision Fast Facts File Reading Explained Freshman Commons General Information Housing Human and Organizational Development I've been admitted - now what? Information for Incoming Students International Students Joint Travel Know Your City Living on Campus Merit Scholarships Mid-Year Reports MOSAIC - VU's Multicultural Student Recruitment Program move-in Music Nashville Peabody College of Education and Human Development Political Life at Vanderbilt Preparing for College PreVU Registering for Classes Rites of Spring Road Shows Scholarships and Financial Aid School of Engineering Social Media in Higher Education Standardized Testing Student Life Study Abroad Summer The College Essay Transfer Students Uncategorized Vanderbilt Blogs Vanderbilt in Pop Culture Vandy Athletics Video Visiting Vanderbilt Visit Vanderbilt VU Admissions Statistics Waitlist