Skip to main content

“Wave on Wave”

Posted by on Wednesday, December 19, 2007 in Early Decision, Preparing for College.

The ED1 wave has just passed here at 2305 West End Avenue. About a week and a half ago I visited the Georgia Aquarium in downtown Atlanta. It’s stunning. So big you can’t see it all from any one vantage point, and can only be absorbed in small portions. Out of all of it though, my favorite exhibit is the tide water tank. The exhibit is a curved tank which extends above your head and is filled with coral and wonderfully happy and colorful fish. The wonder of it all though is that every few minutes you could watch the waves roll in. Everything roils asunder. The swift tumult of the bubbly teal water jostles every fish and anemone, and just as quickly, moves on. Serenity and calm regains until the next wave comes.

I was never denied to any college I ever applied to, but I have had someone else’s decision dramatically change the direction of my life with the loss of a job (when I was in grad school). I remember being livid, inconsolable in fact, and feeling as though the whole plan I had worked out in my head was tumbling away from me. What I know now, and what John Lennon so famously sings, is that “Life is what happens when you’re busy making other plans.” I found a calling for which I would not have otherwise thought to listen, had things worked out with Plan A. I know now that I am more comfortable with adversity, the same way I guess the fish gets used to the waves.

I think more about the students we don’t admit than the students we do. It is a tough holistic process. Nine out of every ten students we ultimately say no to, could be very successful at Vanderbilt. And sometimes small individual differences matter in a big way. This process of presenting yourself to others and having them generate a judgment is not a finite process. It comes in waves. It comes when you apply for a summer internship, or to be a resident assistant in your res hall, or to law school, and ultimately to a job (check that, to lots of jobs). The judgment of that group pertains to you, but it does not become you. In your most honest moments, if you can say that you have done right by you, and have presented yourself in the most genuine way possible, and a college does not admit you based on that presentation, I believe that is the college’s fault. Vanderbilt included. Keep your head up.


  • Brad

    December 19th, 2007

    Hello Blogging Friends,

    Admissions data can be found at the following link on College Confidential.

  • Anonymous

    December 19th, 2007

    Hello, so I know you hate hearing this question…but if we got accepted early decision, approximately what gpa (weighted/unweighted) do we need to maintain? I know we are supposed to keep up our grades as we have done before,but I am curious as to the approximate number gpa.

  • Ken

    December 20th, 2007

    Anonymous — it kind of depends on your high school, but we’d expect you to pretty much keep up the grades you’ve made so far. If you were an A student before, an A- year is probably OK, but a B- year could be trouble.

  • Anonymous

    January 10th, 2008

    It’s mentioned somewhere on the Admissions pages that about 1/3 of regular decision applications receive a final decision (yes or no)after 2 reads, and the other 2/3s are shelved for further review by Admissions Committee.
    The question is: Are those Yes/No applications notified or do they still have to wait until April to find out ?
    Thanks !